ANTIPHONE
"Let our writings be open to all people. Let them
see what out moral code is like! We need not be afraid of this test, for we
have a pure heart and a clean spirit. Let the nations investigate the
habitations of the children of Israel, and of their own accord convince
themselves of what they are really like! They will then exclaim for certain
with Balaam, when he went out to curse Israel: 'How beautiful are thy tents
O Israel: how beautiful thy homes!'
"In its attitude towards non-Jews, the Jewish
religion is the most tolerant of the the religions in the world.... The
precepts of the ancient Rabbis, though inimical to Gentiles, cannot be
applied in any way to Christians."
"A whole series of opinions can be quoted from the
writings of the highest Rabbinical authorities to prove that these teachers
inculcated in their own people a great love and respect for Christians, in
order that they might look upon Christians, who believe in the true God, as
brothers, and pray for them." "We hereby declare the the Talmud does not
contain anything inimical to Christians."
PROLOGUE
Many people who are interested in the Jewish
question are wont to ask whether or not there is anything in the Talmud
which is not beautiful and sublime, and entirely removed from anything like
hatred of Christians. The confusion of opinion about the matter is so great,
that to listen to those who argue so wisely about it, you would think that
they were discussing a very ancient and remote race of people, and not the
people of Israel who live in our midst according to an unchanging moral code
by which the religious and social life of the Jews has been regulated to
this day.
This being so, I have undertaken to show what the
Talmud really teaches about Christians, and thus satisfy the wishes of those
who desire to find out about this doctrine from genuine original sources.
To this end I have translated the best known
Talmudic books which refer to the Christians, and have arranged these
sources in such order as to bring out clearly the picture of a Christian as
represented to the Jews by the Talmud.
Lest I be accused of using a corrupted text of the
Talmud or of not having interpreted it correctly, as is generally the case
with those who have attempted to disclose secret Jewish teachings, I have
placed the Hebrew text opposite the Latin.
I have divided the whole into two sections, the
first of which treats of the teachings of the Talmud about Christians, and
the other, the rules which Jews are obliged to follow when living among the
Christians.
I preface these with a brief discussion about the
Talmud itself in the following chapter.
THE TALMUD
The Talmud gets its name from the word Lamud -
taught, and means The Teaching. By metonymy it is taken to mean the book
which contains the Teaching, which is called Talmud, that is, the doctrinal
book which alone fully expounds and explains all the knowledge and teaching
of the Jewish people.
As to the origin of the Talmud, the Rabbis regard
Moses as its first author. They hold that, besides the written law which
Moses received from God on Mount Sinai on tables of stone, which is called
Torah Schebiktab, he also received interpretations of it, or the oral law,
which is called Torah Shebeal Peh. They say that this is the reason why
Moses remained so long on the mountain, as God could have given him the
written law in one day.
Moses is said to have transmitted this oral law to
Joshua; Joshua in turn to the seventy Elders; the Elders to the Prophets,
and the Prophets to the Great Synagogue. It is held that it was later
transmitted successively to certain Rabbis until it was no longer possible
to retain it orally.
Whatever may be said about this story of the Rabbis,
it is sufficiently known to us that before the birth of Christ, schools
existed in Palestine in which sacred literature was taught. The commentaries
of the Doctors of the law were noted down on charts and lists as an aid to
memory, and these, when collected together, formed the beginnings of the
Jewish Talmud.
In the second century after Christ, Rabbi Jehuda
who, because of the sanctity of his life, was called The Saint, and The
Prince,realizing that the learning of the Jews was diminishing, that their
oral law was being lost, and that the Jewish people were being dispersed,
was the first to consider ways and means of restoring and preserving their
oral law. He collected all the lists and charts and from them he made a book
which was called the Sepher Mischnaioth, or Mischnah - a Deuterosis, or
secondary law. He divided it into six parts, each of which was divided into
many chapters. We shall consider these later.
The Mischnah is the foundation and the principal
part of the whole Talmud. This book was accepted by the Jews everywhere and
was recognized as their authentic code of law. It was expounded in their
Academies in Babylon - at Sura, Iumbaditha and Nehardea - and in their
Academies in Palestine - at Tiberias, Iamnia and Lydda.
As their interpretations increased with the passing
of time, the disputations and decisions of the doctors of the law concerning
the Mischnah were written down, and these writings constituted another part
of the Talmud called the Gemarah.
These two parts are so disposed throughout the whole
Talmud that the Mischnah serves first as a kind of text of the law, and is
followed by the Gemarah as an analysis of its various opinions leading to
definite decisions.
All the precepts of the Mischnah, however, were not
discussed in the Jewish schools. Those whose use was nullified by the
destruction of the Temple, and those whose observation was possible only in
the Holy Land were not commented upon. Their explanation was left until the
coming of Elias and the Messiah. For this reason some parts of the Mischnah
are lacking in the Gemarah.
In interpreting the Mischnah of Rabbi Jehuda, the
schools of Palestine and Babylon followed each their own method, and by thus
following their own way gave rise to a twofold Gemarah - the Jerusalem and
the Babylonian versions. The author of the Jerusalem version was Rabbi
Jochanan, who was head of the synagogue in Jerusalem for eighty years. He
wrote thirty-nine
chapters of commentaries on the Mischnah which he compiled in the year 230
A.D.
The Babylonian Gemarah, however, was not compiled by
any one person, nor at any one time. Rabbi Aschi began it in 327 A.D and
labored over it for sixty years. He was followed by Rabbi Maremar about the
year 427 A.D., and it was completed by Rabbi Abina about the year 500 A.D.
The Babylonian Gemarah has thirty-six chapters of interpretations.
This twofold Gemarah, added to the Mischnah, makes
also a twofold Talmud: The Jerusalem version, which, on account of its
brevity and obscurity, is not much used; and the Babylonian version, which
has been held in the highest esteem by Jews of all times.
The Gemarah is followed by additions called
Tosephoth. It was thus that Rabbi Chaia first styled his opinions on the
Mischnah which were made by the doctors outside the schools were called
Baraietoth, or extraneous opinions.
These Commentaries were further supplemented by
other decisions called Piske Tosephoth, short theses and simple principles.
For nearly five hundred years after the Babylonian
Talmud was completed, the study of literature was greatly hampered partly
due to public calamities and partly owing to dissensions among the scholars.
But in the eleventh century others wrote further additions to the Talmud.
Chief among these were the Tosephoth of Rabbi Ascher.
Besides these there appeared the Perusch of Rabbi
Moische ben Maimon, called by the Jews Rambam for short, by the Christians
Maimonides, and by Rabbi Schelomo, Iarchi or Raschi.
Thus, the Mischna, Gemarah, Tosephoth, the marginal
notes of Rabbi Ascher, the Piske Tosephoth and the Perusch Hamischnaioth of
Maimonides, all collected into one, constitute a vast work which is called
the Talmud.
The main parts of the Talmud, which we mentioned
above, are six:
- ZERAIM:
concerning seeds. It treats of seeds, fruits, herbs, trees; of the public
and domestic use of fruits, of different
seeds, etc.
MOED:
concerning festivals. It treats of the time when the Sabbath and other
festivals are to begin, ended and celebrated.
NASCHIM:
concerning women. It treats of marrying and repudiating wives, their
duties, relations, sicknesses, etc.
NEZIKIN:
concerning damages. It treats of damages suffered by men and animals,
penalties and compensations.
KODASCHIM:
concerning holiness. It treats of sacrifices and various sacred rites.
TOHOROTH:
concerning purifications. It treats of the soiling and purifying of
vessels, bedclothes and other things.
Each of these six parts, which the Jews call
Schishah Sedarim - six orders or ordinances - is divided into books or
tracts, called Massiktoth, and the books into chapters, or Perakim.
- ZERAIM.
Contains eleven books or Masechtoth.
1. BERAKTOTH -
Benedictions and prayers. Treats of liturgical rules.
2. PEAH - Corner of a field. Treats of the corners and gleanings of the
filed...The olives and grapes to be left to the poor.
3. DEMAI - Doubtful things. Whether or not tithes must be paid on such.
4. KILAIM - Mixtures. Treats of various mixings of seeds.
5. SCHEBIITH - the Sevents. Treats of the Sabbatical Year.
6. TERUMOTH - Offerings and Oblations. The Heave offerings for the
priests.
7. MAASEROTH - the Tithes, to be given to the Levites.
8. MAASER SCHENI - the Second Tithe.
9. CHALLAH - the Dough, the portion to be given thereof to the Priests.
10. ORLAH - the Uncircumcised. Treats about the fruits of a tree during
the first three years after its plantings.
11. BIKKURIM - the First Fruits to be brought to the Temple.
MOED.
Contains twelve Books or Masechtoth.
1. SCHABBATH -
the Sabbath. Treats of kinds of work prohibited on that day.
2. ERUBHIN - Combinations. Contains precepts about food for the Sabbath
eve.
3. SCHEKALIM - Passover. Treats of the laws relating to the Feast of
Passover and the Paschal Lamb.
4. SCHEKALIM - Shekel. Treats of the size and weight of the shekel.
5. IOMA - the Day of Atonement. Treats of prescriptions for that Day.
6. SUKKAH - the Tabernacle. Treats of the laws concerning the feast of
Tabernacles.
7. BETSAH - the Egg of the Day of Feast. Treats of the kind of work
prohibited and permitted on the festivals.
8. ROSCH HASCHANAH - New Year. Treats of the Feast of New Year.
9. TAANITH - Fasts. Treats of public fasts.
10. MEGILLAH - the Scroll. Treats of the reading of the Book of Esther.
Contains the description of the Feast of Purim.
11. MOED KATON - Minor Feast. treats of laws relating to the days
intervening between the first and last days of
Pesach and Succoth.
12. CHAGIGAH - Comparison of rites on on the three feats of Pesach,
Sukkoth and Tabernacles.
NASCHIM.
Contains seven Books or Masechtoth.
1. JEBBAMOTH -
Sisters in Law. Treats of Levirate marriage.
2. KETHUBOTH - Marriage Deeds. Treats of dower and marriage settlements.
3. KIDDUSCHIN - Betrothals.
4. GITTIN - booklet on Divorces.
5. NEDARIM - Vows. Treats of vows and their annulment.
6. NAZIR - the Nazarite. Treats of the laws concerning the Nazarites and
those who separate themselves from the world and consecrate themselves to
God.
7. SOTAH - the Woman suspected of adultery.
NEZIKIN.
Contains ten Books or Masechtoth.
1. BABA KAMA -
First Gate. Treats of Damages and Injuries and their remedies.
2. BABA METSIA - Middle Gate. Treats of laws concerning found property,
concerning trust, concerning buying and
selling, lending, hiring and renting.
3. BABA BATHRA - Last Gate. Treats of laws concerning real estate and
commerce, mostly based on the traditional
law. Also concerning hereditary succession.
4. SANHEDRIN - Courts. Treats of the courts and their proceedings, and the
punishment of capital crimes.
5. MAKKOTH - Stripes. The 40 stripes (minus one) inflicted on criminals.
6. SCHEBUOTH - Oaths. Treats different kinds of oaths.
7. EDAIOTH - Testimonies. Contains a collection of traditional laws and
decisions gathers from the testimonies of the
distinguished teachers.
8. HORAIOTH- Decisions. Treats of the sentences of Judges and the
punishment of transgressors.
9. ABHODAH ZARAH - Idolatry.
10. ABHOTH - Fathers. Treats of laws of the fathers. It is called also
PIRKE ABHOTH.
KODASCHIM.
Contains eleven Books or Masechtoth.
1. ZEBBACHIM -
Sacrifices. Treats of animal sacrifices and the mode of their offering.
2. CHULIN - Profane things. Treats of the traditional manner of
slaughtering animals for ordinary use.
3. MENACHOTH - Meat-offerings. Treats of meat-and-drink offerings.
4. BEKHOROTH - the First Born. Treats of the laws concerning the first
born of man and animals.
5. ERAKHIN - Estimations. Treats of the mode in which persons dedicated to
the Lord by a vow arel legally appraised
in order to be redeemed.
6. TEMURAH - Exchange. Treats of the laws concerning sanctified things
having been exchanged.
7. MEILAH - Trespass, Sacrilege. Treats of the sins subject to the
punishment of excision, and their expiation by
sacrifices.
8. KERITHUTH - Excisions - Treats of the sins subject to the punishment of
excision, and their expiation by sacrifices.
9. TAMID - the Daily Sacrifice- Describes the Temple services connected
with the daily morning and evening offerings.
10. MIDDOTH - Measurements. Describes the measurements and description of
the Temple.
11. KINNIM - the Birds' Nests. Treats of the sacrifices consisting of
fowls, the offerings of the poor, etc.
TOHOROTH.
Contains twelve Books or Masechtoth.
1. KELLIM -
Vessels. Treats of the conditions under which domestic utensils, garments,
etc. receive ritual cleanness.
2. OHOLOTH - Tents. Treats of tents and houses, and how polluted and
purified.
3. NEGAIM - Plagues. Treats of the laws relating to Leprosy.
4. PARAH - the Heifer. Treats of the laws concerning the red heifer and
the use of its ashes for the purification of the
unclean.
5. TOHOROTH - Purifications. Treats of some lesser degrees of uncleanness
lasting only until sunset.
6. MIKVAOTH - Wells. Treats of the conditions under which wells and
reservoirs are fit to be used for ritual
purifications.
7. NIDDAH - Menstruation. Treats of the legal uncleanness arising from
certain conditions in women.
8. MAKSCHIRIN - Preparations. Treats of liquids that prepare and dispose
seeds and fruits to receive ritual
uncleanness.
9. ZABHIM - Concerning nightly pollution and gonorrhea. Treats on the
uncleanness arising from such secretions.
10 TEBHUL IOM - Daily washing.
11. IADAIM - Hands. Treats of the ritual uncleanness of hands, according
to the traditional law, and of their purification.
12. OKETSIN - Stalks of fruit. Treats of stalks and shells of fruit as
conveying ritual uncleanness.
The complete Talmud contains 63 books in 524
chapters.
Added to these are four other shorts tracts, which
have not been included in the regular Talmud. They have been added by later
writers and exponents.
These
four are:
MASSEKHETH SOPHERIM - the Tract of Scribes. Treats of the mode of writing
the books of the law. Has 21 chapters. EBHEL RABBETI - a large treatise on
Mourning. Has 14 chapters. KALLAH - the Bride. On the acquisition of the
bride. Has one chapter. MASSEKHETH DEREKH ERETS - the Conduct of Lide.
Divided into RABBAH - major parts, and ZUTA - the minor parts. Has 16
chapters. At the end is added a special chapter - PEREK SCHALOM - on Peace.
Since the Talmud was such a voluminous and
disordered work, there was a need of a compendium which would facilitate its
study. To supply this need, therefore, Rabbi Isaac ben Jacob Alphassi, in
1032, published a Shorter Talmud, which he called Halakhoth -
Constitutions. He omitted all lengthy discussions and preserved only those
parts which had to do with the practical things of life. Since this work,
however, had no order to it, it was not considered of great worth.
The first to issue a well ordered work on Jewish Law
was Maimonides, styled the "Eagle of the Synagogue." In 1180 he produced his
celebrated work Miscnhah Torah - Repetition of the Law, also called
Iad Chazakah - the Strong Hand. It contains four parts or volumes and 14
books and includes the whole Talmud. Maimonides also included much
philosophical discussion in this work and attempted to establish many laws
of his own. Because of this he was excommunicated by his people and
condemned to death. He fled to Egypt where he died in the year 1205.
In spite
of this, the value of his work increased in time, and for a while an
expurgated version was held in the highest esteem by the Jews. A drawback to
this work is that it contains many laws which were of no value after the
destruction of the Temple.
An edition of the work of Maimonides, expurgated of
all his philosophical innovations and of all the old, useless laws, was
edited in 1340, in strict accord with the ideas of the Rabbis, by Jacob ben
Ascher, to which he gave the name Arbaa Turim
The Four Orders, which are:
- ORACH CHAIIM:
The seeds of Life, and treats of the daily life in the home and in the
Synagogue.
IORE DEAH:
which teaches knowledge about foods, purifications and other religious
laws.
CHOSCHEN
HAMMISCHPAT: private judgments about civil and criminal laws.
EBHEN HAEZER:
The Rock of Help, which treats of the laws of marriage.
Since Alphasi, Maimonides and Jacob ben Ascher
disagreed on many points, which gave rise to different interpretations of
the same law, there was great need of a book which would contain short,
concise solutions to controversies, and which would supply to the Jewish
people a law book worthy of the name.
Joseph Karo, a Rabbi of Palestine (born 1488, died
1577), supplied this need by his celebrated commentary on the Arbaa
Turim, which he called Schulchan Arukh - the Prepared Table.
Since, however, the customs of oriental Jews differed greatly from those
of western Jews, even the Schulchan Arukh, of Joseph Karo did not
suffice for Jews everywhere. And for this reason
Rabbi Mosche Isserles wrote a commentary on the Schulchan Arukh,
entitled Darkhe Mosche, the Way of Moses, which received the same
acceptance in the West as the work of Joseph Karo in the East.
At the present time, the Schulchan Arukh is
regarded as the obligatory Law Code of the Jews, and they use it principally
in their studies. Many commentaries have been written on each part of this
book.
An important point to note is that this work has
always been regarded by the Jews as holy. They have always held it, and
still hold it, as more important than the Sacred Scriptures.The Talmud
itself shows this very clearly:
In the
tract Babha Metsia, fol. 33a, we read:
"Those who devote themselves to reading the Bible exercise a certain virtue,
but not very much; those who study the Mischnah exercise virtue for
which they will receive a reward; those, however, who take upon themselves
to study the Gemarah exercise the highest virtue."
Likewise
in the tract Sopherim XV, 7, fol. 13b:
"The Sacred Scriptures is like water, the Mischnah wine, and the
Gemarah aromatic wine.
The following is a well-known and highly praised
opinion in the writings of the Rabbis:
"My son, give heed to the words of the scribes
rather than to the words of the law."
The reason for this is found in the tract
Sanhedrin X, 3, f.88b:
"He who transgresses the words of the scribes sins
more gravely than the transgressors of the words of the law."
Also when there are differences of opinion between
the Law and the doctors, both must be taken as the words of the Lord God. In
the tract Erubhin, f.13b, where it is related that there was a
difference of opinion between the two schools of Hillel and Schamai, it is
concluded that:
"The words of both are the words of the living God."
In the book Mizbeach, cap. V, we find the
following opinion:
"There is nothing superior to the Holy Talmud."
Contemporary defenders of the Talmud speak of it almost in the same way.
What Christians have thought of the Talmud is amply
proved by the many edicts and decrees issued about it, by which the supreme
rulers in Church and State proscribed it many times and condemned this
sacred Secondary Law Code of the Jews to the flames.
In 553 the Emperor Justinian forbade the spread of
the Talmudic books throughout the Roman Empire. In the 13th century "Popes
Gregory IX and Innocent IV condemned the books of the Talmud as containing
every kind of vileness and blasphemy against Christian truth, and ordered
them to be burned because they spread many horrible heresies."
Later, they were condemned by many other Roman
Pontiffs - Julius III, Paul IV, Pius IV, Pius V, Gregory XIII, Clement VIII,
Alexander VII, Benedict XIV, and by others who issued new editions of the
Index of Forbidden Books according to the orders of the Fathers of the
Council of Trent, and even in our own time.
At the beginning of the 16th century, when the peace
of the Church was disturbed by new religions, the Jews began to distribute
the Talmud openly, aided by the art of printing then recently invented. The
first printed edition of the whole Talmud, containing all its blasphemies
against the Christian religion, was published in Venice in the year 1520.
And almost all Jewish books published in that century, which was favorable
to them, are complete and genuine.
Towards the end of the 16th century and at the
beginning of the 17th, when many famous men undertook diligently to study
the Talmud, the Jews, fearing for themselves, began to expunge parts of the
Talmud which was published at Basle in 1578 has been mutilated in many
places.
And at Synod in Poland, in the year 1631, the Rabbis
of Germany and many other countries declared that nothing which would annoy
the Christians and cause persecution of Israel, should be printed. For this
reason there are signs of many things missing in the Jewish books which were
published in the following century and thereafter. The Rabbis explain from
memory what these
things mean, for they possess the genuine books which Christians rarely see.
However, Jewish books were published later with very
few mutilations in Holland - where the Jews who were expelled from Spain
were kindly received. The Talmud published there in 1644 - 1648 is almost
similar to the Venetian edition.
The latest device invented to deceive the censors
was to insert the word haiah (was) with the genuine text, as if to
indicate that the matter in question once had its place there. But by so
doing they only cleanse the outside of the cup. For in many places they do
show what they mean, ex.gr. by the words gam attah, "even now,"
viz. "this law obliges"; and aphilu bazzeman hazzeh, "even
to this day" viz. "this law holds," and such like.
We must add a few remarks about that other very well
known book of the Jews, called the ZOHAR.
According to some Rabbis, Moses, after he had been instructed in the
interpretation of the law on Mount Sinai, did not pass this information to
Joshua nor he to the Elders, but to Aaron, Aaron to Eleazer, and so on until
the oral teachings had been put into book form called the ZOHAR, so called
from the name ZEHAR, meaning to shine forth. For it is an illustration of
the books of Moses, a commentary on the Pentateuch.
The author is said to have been R. Schimeon ben
Jochai, a disciple of R. Akibha who, fifty years after the destruction of
the Temple, ended his life as a martyr about the year 120 A.D. in Hadrian's
war against the Jews. Since, however, names of men appear in this book who
lived many centuries after the year indicated, and since neither Rambam (R.
Mosche ben Nachman), nor R. Ascher, who died about the year 1248 A.D., make
no mention of it, it is more likely that those are nearer the truth who say
that the book of Zohar first saw the light about the 13th century.
Especially is this considered likely since about this time a book was
produced which is similar in argument and style to the Chaldaic type of
writing.
It consists of three volumes in large octavo.
Many other works have been published by the Jewish
teachers which are used in the study of Jewish law, and which are held in
high esteem since they explain many obscure passages in the Talmud. Some of
them are cited in this book, and are as follows:
BAR - Declaration, elucidation, Commentary on
another Commentary. These declarations differ from one another.
HALAKOTH - usually written HILKHOTH - Decisions or
Dissertations. Separate books of Holy Scriptures and of the Talmud by
different Rabbis: Maimonides, Beshai, Edels, Moses of Kotzen, Kimchi and
others. In most cases citations are given from HILKOTH AKUM by Maimonides.
These contain dissertations on stars and planets and the status of nations.
There is another - HILKOTH MAAKHALOTH ASAVOROTH -
dissertation about forbidden foods.
IUCHASIN or SEPHER IUCHASIN - dissertations on
lineage. Treats of Sacred and Jewish history from the beginning of theworld
until 1500. Printed at Cracow, 1580.
JALKUT - a collected commentary from various ancient
books. Supposed to have not a literal but allegorical meaning. Author: Rabbi
Shimeon of Frankfurt.
KED HAKKEMACH - Barrel of flour. Contains places of
theological communities in alphabetical order. Author: Rabbi Bechai of
Lublin.
MAGEN ABRAHAM - Shield of Abraham. Author: Perizola.
MIZBEACH HAZZAHABH - the Golden Altar. A Cabalistic
book. Author: R. Schelomon ben Rabbi Mordechai. Printed at Basle, in 1602.
MACHZOR - a Cycle. Book of Prayers used on great
festivals.
MENORATH HAMMAOR - Candlestick of light. A Talmudic
book. Contains Aggadoth and Medraschim. i.e., allegorical and historical
comments on the entire Talmud. Author: Rabbi Isaac Abhuhabh. Printed in
1544.
MAIENE HAIESCHUAH - Fountains of the Savior. An
exquisite Commentary on Daniel by Rabbi Isaac Abarbanel. There are numerous
disputations against Christians. Printed in 1551.
MIKRA GEDOLAH - the Great Convocation. A Hebrew
Bible with commentaries by R. Salomon Iarchi and R. Ezra.
MASCHMIA IESCHUAH - The Preacher of Salvation.
Explanations on all the Prophets. On future redemption. Author: R. Abarbanel.
NIZZACHON - Victory. Attacks on Christians and on
the Four Gospels. Author: Rabbi Lipman. Printed in 1559.
SEPHER IKKARIM - Book on fundamentals or articles of
faith. It contains one very bitter attack against the Christian faith.
EN ISRAEL - the Eye of Israel. A celebrated book.
Has a second part - BETH JAKOBH - the House of Jacob. Embraces the most
delightful Talmudic histories. Printed in Venice, in 1547.
SCHAARE ORAH - the Gates of Light. A most celebrated
Cabalistic book. Author: Ben Joseph Gekatilia.
SCHEPHAA TAL - Abundance of Dew. A Cabalistic book.
A key to the book of Zohar and other similar books. Author: Rabbi Schephtel
Horwitz of Prague.
TOLDOTH IESCHU - the Generations of Jesus. A little
pamphlet full of blasphemies and maledictions. Contains the history of
Christ. Full of false and deceiving manifestations.
In preparing this booklet I have used the following
source material:
The TALMUD. Edition of Amsterdam, 1644-48, in 14
volumes.
SCHULKHAN ARUKH, by Rabbi Joseph Karo. Edition of
Venice, 1594. Without commentaries.
IORE DEAH. Numerous quotations. Edition of Krakow.
ZOHAR. Edition of Amsterdam, 1805. 3 volumes.
MIKRA GEDOLAH. Edition of Amsterdam, 1792, 12
volumes, edition of Basle, 1620, 2 volumes, edition of Venice.
HILKHOTH AKUM, of R. Maimonides, edition by Vossius,
1675
As auxillary works I have used:
JOANNES BUXDORFIUS. a Lexicon Chaldaicum, Talmudicum
et Rabbinicum, Base, 1640. b. De Abreviaturis Hebraicis; Operis Talmudis
Recensio; Biblicothea Rabbinica. Basle, 1712. c. Synagoga Judaica. Basle,
1712.
JOH. CHRISTOPHORI WAGENSEILII, Sota. Aldtorfi
Noricum, 1674.
GEORGII ELIEZ EDZARDI: Tractatus talmudici "AVODA
SARA." Hamburg, 1705.
JACOBI ECKER: "Der Judenspiegel im Lichte der
Wahrheit," (The Jewish Mirror in the Light of Truth). Paderborn, 1884.
AUGUST ROHLING: Die Polemik und das Manschenopfer
des Rabbinismus. (The Polemics and Human Sacrifice of Rabbinism).Paderborn,
1883.
I have only used the works of those who are held in
the highest esteem by the Jews themselves, and to whom the Jews appeal when
disputing with Christians, by quoting impartially the opinions of these
learned men. Their great dilligence in quoting from the texts of books which
I was able to examine, has been a proof to me that I used the same diligence
even in quoting from
less known sources to which they have much greater access than I.
PART ONE
THE TEACHING OF THE TALMUD
CONCERNING CHRISTIANS
First we shall see what the Talmud teaches about
Jesus Christ, the founder of Christianity; and secondly, about his
followers, the Christians.
CHAPTER I
JESUS CHRIST IN THE TALMUD
Many passages in the Talmudic books treat of the
birth, life, death, and teachings of Jesus Christ. He is not always referred
to by the same name, however, but is diversely called "That Man," "A Certain
One," "The Carpenter's Son," "The One Who Was Hanged," etc.
Article I. - CONCERNING THE NAMES
OF JESUS CHRIST
1. The real name of Christ in Hebrew is Jeschua
Hanotsri - Jesus the Nazarene. He is called Notsri from the city of Nazareth
in which he was brought up. Thus in the Talmud Christians also are called
Notsrim - Nazarenes. Since the word Jeschua means "Savior," the name Jesus
rarely occurs in the Jewish books. It is almost always abbreviated to Jeschu,
which is maliciously taken as if it were composed of the initial letters of
the three words Immach SCHemo Vezikro - "May his name and memory be blotted
out."
2. In the Talmud Christ is called Otho Isch - "That
man," i.e. the one who is known to all. In the tract Abhodah Zarah, 6a, we
read: "He is called a Christian who follows the false teachings of that man,
who taught them to celebrate the feast on the first day of the Sabbath, that
is, to worship on the first day after the Sabbath"
3. Elsewhere he is simply called Peloni - "A Certain
One." In Chagigah, 4b, we read: "Mary...the mother of a certain one, of whom
it is related in Schabbath..." That this Mary is none other than the mother
of Jesus will be shown later.
4. Out of contempt, Jesus is also called Naggar bar
naggar - "the carpenter son of a carpenter", also Ben charsch etaim - "the
son of a wood worker."
5. He is also called Talui - "The one who was
hanged." Rabbi Samuel, the son of Mair, in the Hilch. Akum of Maimonides,
refers to the fact that it was forbidden to take part in the Christian feats
of Christmas and Easter because they were celebrated on account of him who
was hanged. And Rabbi Aben Ezra, in a commentary on Genes. also calls him
Talui, whose image the Emperor Constantine reproduced on his banner. "...in
the days of Constantine, who made a change of religion and
placed the figure of the one who was hanged on his banner."
Article II. - THE LIFE OF CHRIST
The Talmud teaches that Jesus Christ was
illegitimate and was conceived during menstruation; that he had the soul of
Esau; that he was a fool, a conjurer, a seducer; that he was crucified,
buried in hell and set up as an idol ever since by his followers.
1. ILLEGITIMATE AND CONCEIVED DURING
MENSTRUATION
The following is narrated in the Tract Kallah,
1b:"Once when the Elders were seated at the Gate, two young men passed by,
one of whom had his covered, the other with his head bare.Rabbi Eliezer
remarked that the one in his bare head was illegitimate, a mamzer. Rabbi
Jehoschua said that he was conceived during menstruation, ben niddah. Rabbi
Akibah, however, said that he was both. Whereupon the others asked Rabbi
Akibah why he dared to contradict his colleagues. He answered that he could
prove what he said. He went therefore to the boy's mother whom he saw
sitting in the market place selling vegetables and said to her: "My
daughter, if you will answer truthfully what I am going to ask you, I
promise that you will be saved in the next life." She demanded that he would
swear to keep his promise, and Rabbi Akibah did so -but with his lips only,
for in his heart he invalidated his oath. Then he said: "Tell me, what kind
of son is this of yours"? To which she replied: "The day I was married I was
having menstruation, and because of this my husband left me. But an evil
spirit came and slept with me and from this intercourse my son was born to
me." Thus it was proved that this young man was not only illegitimate but
also conceived during the menstruation of his mother. And when his
questioners heard this they declared: "Great indeed was Rabbi Akibah when he
corrected his Elders"! And they exclaimed: "Bleddes be the Lord God of
Israel who revealed his secret to Rabbi Akibah the son of Joseph"! That the
Jews understand this story to refer to Jesus and his mother, Mary, is
clearly demonstrated in their book Toldath Jeschu - "The Generations of
Jesus" - where the birth of our Savior is narrated in almost the same words.
Another story of this kind is narrated in Sanhedrin, 67a: "Of all who are
guilty of death by the Law, he alone is caught by a ruse. How is it done?
They light a candle in an inner room and place witnesses in an adjoining
room outside where they can see him and hear his voice, but where they
cannot be seen by him. Then the one whom he tried to seduce says to him
"Please repeat here privately what you told me before." If the seducer
repeats what he said, the others ask him "But how shall we leave our God who
is in heaven and serve idols?" If the
seducer repents, then all is well.But if he says "This is our duty and it is
right for us to do so," then the witnesses outside, who have heard him,
bring him before the judge and stone him to death. This is what they did to
the son of Stadi in Lud, and they hanged him on the eve of the Passover.
Forthis son of Stada was the son of Pandira. For Rabbi Chasda tells us that
Pandira was the husband of Stada, his mother, and he lived during the time
Paphus the son of Jehuda. But his
mother was stada, Mary of Magdala (a ladies' hairdresser) who, as it is said
in Pumbadita, deserted her husband."
The meaning of this is that his Mary was called
Stada, that is, a prostitute, because, according to what was taught at
Pumbadita, she left her husband and commited adultery. This is also recorded
in the Jerusalem Talmud and by Maimonides. That the mention here is of Mary,
the mother of Jesus, is verified in the Tract Chagigah, 4b: "When Rabbi
Bibhai was visited once by the Death Angel (the devil), the latter said to
his assistant: "Go and bring to me Mary the hairdresser" (that is, kill
her). He went and brought Mary the children's hairdresser - in place of the
other Mary." A marginal note explains this passage as follows:
"This story of Mary the Ladies' hairdresser happened
under the Second Temple. She was the mother of Peloni, "that man," as he is
called in the tract Schabbath." In Schabbath the passage referred to says:
"Rabbi Elizer said to the Elders: "Did not the son Stada practice Egyptian
magic by cutting it into his flesh?" They replied: "He was a fool, and we do
not pay attention to what fools do. The son of Stada, Pandra's son, etc." as
above in Sanhedrin, 67a. This magic of the son of Stada is explained as
follows in the book Beth Jacobh, fol. 127 a: "The Magi, before they left
Egypt, took special care not to put their magic in writing lest other
peoples might come to learn it. But he devised a new way by which he
inscribed it on his skin, or made cuts in his skin and inserted it there and
which, when the wounds healed up, did not show what they meant." Buxtorf
says: "There is little doubt who this Ben Stada was, or who the Jews
understood him to be. Although the Rabbis in their additions to the Talmud
try to hide their malice and say that it is not Jesus Christ, their deceit
is plainly evident, and many things prove that they wrote and understood all
these things about him. In the first place, they also call him the son of
Pandira. Jesus the Nazarene is thus called in other passages of the Talmud
where express mention is made of Jesus the son of Pandira. St. John
Damascene also, in his Genealogy of Christ, mentions Panthera and the Son
of Panthera. "Secondly, this Stada is said to be Mary, and this Mary the
mother of Peloni "that certain one," by which without doubt Jesus is meant.
For in this way they were accustomed to cover up his name because they were
afraid to mention it. If we had copies of the original manuscripts they
would certainly prove this. And this also was the name of the mother of
Jesus the Nazarene. "Thirdly, he is called the Seducer of the People. The
Gospels testify that Jesus was called this by the Jews, and their writings
to this day are proof that they still call him by this name. "Fourthly, he
is called "the one who was hanged," which clearly refers to the crucifixion
of Christ, especially since a reference to the time "on the eve of the
Passover" is added, which coincides with the time of the crucifixion of
Jesus. In Sanhedrin they wrote as follows:
"On the eve of the Passover they
hanged Jesus"
"Fifthly, as to what the Jerusalem Talmud says about
the two disciples of the Elders who were sent as witnesses to spy on him,
and who were afterwards brought forward as witnesses against him: This
refers to the two "false witnesses" of whom the Evangelists Matthew and Luke
make mention.
"Sixthly, concerning what they say about the son of Stada that he practiced
Egyptian magical arts by cutting into his flesh: the same accusation is made
against Christ in their hostile book Toldoth Jeschu. "Lastly, the time
corresponds. For it is said that this son of Stada lived in the days of
Paphus the son of Jehuda, who was a contemporary of Rabbi Akibah. Akibah,
however, lived at the time of the Ascension of Christ, and for some time
after. Mary is also said to have lived under the Second Temple. All this
clearly proves that they secretly and blasphemously understand this son of
Stada to be Jesus Christ the son of Mary. "Other circumstances may seem to
contradict this. But that is nothing new in Jewish writings and is done on
purpose so that Christians may not easily detect their trickery."
2. Furthermore, "In the
secret books, which are not permitted to fall easily into the hands of
Christians, they say that the soul of Esau came into Christ, that he was
therefore evil and that he was Esau himself."
3. By some he is called
a FOOL and INSANE In Schabbath, 104b: "They, [the Elders] said to him [Eliezer]:
"He was a fool, and no one pays attention to fools."
4. A CONJURER AND MAGICIAN
In the infamous book Toldoth Jeschu, our Savior is blasphemed as follows:
"And Jesus said: Did not Isaiah and David, my ancestors, prophesy about me?
The Lord said to me, thou art my son, today I have begotten thee, etc.
Likewise in another place: The Lord said to my Lord, sit thou at my
right hand. Now I ascend to my father who is in heaven and will sit at
his right hand, which you will see with your own eyes. But you, Judas, will
never reach that high.
Then Jesus pronounced the great name of God (IHVH) and continued to do so
until a wind came and took him up between earth and sky. Judas also
pronounced the name of God and he likewise was taken up by the wind. In this
way they both floated around in the air to the amazement of the onlookers.
Then Judas, again pronouncing the Divine Nane, took hold of Jesus and pushed
him down to earth. But Jesus tried to do the same to Judas and thus they
fought together. And when Judas saw he could not win out over the works of
Jesushe pissed on Jesus, and both thus being unclean they fell to earth; nor
could they use the Divine name again until they had washed themselves."
Whether those who believe such devilish lies deserve greater hatred or pity,
I cannot say.
In another place in the same book it is related that
in the house of the Sanctuary there was a stone which the Patriarch Jacob
anointed with oil. On this stone were carved the tetragrammatic letters of
the Name (IHVH), and if anyone could learn from them he could destroy the
world. They therefore decreed that no one must learn them, and they placed
two dogs upon two iron columns before the Sanctuary so that if anyone should
learn them the dogs would bark at him coming out and he would forget the
letters through fear. Then it is related: "Jesus came and entered, learned
the letters and wrote them down on parchment. Then he cut into the flesh of
his thigh and inserted them there, and having pronounced the name, the wound
healed."
5. IDOLATER In the
Tract Sanhedrin (103a) the words of Psalm XCI, 10: "No plague shall come
near thy dwelling," are explained as follows: "That thou mayest never have a
son or a disciple who will salt his food so much that he destroys his taste
in public, like Jesus the Nazarene." To salt one's food too much or to
destroy one's taste, is proverbially said of one who corrupts his morals or
dishonors himself, or who falls into heresy and idolatry and openly preaches
it to others.
6. SEDUCER In the same
book Sanhedrin (107b) we read: "Mar said: Jesus seduced, corrupted and
destroyed Israel."
7. CRUCIFIED Finally as
punishment for his crimes and impiety, he suffered an ignominious death by
being hanged on a cross on the eve of the Passover (as we have seen above).
8. BURIED IN HELL The
book Zohar, III, (282), tells us that Jesus died like a beast and was buried
in that "dirt heap...where they throw the dead bodies of dogs and asses, and
where the sons of Esau [the Christians] and of Ismael [the Turks], also
Jesus and Mahommed, uncircumcized and unclean like dead dogs, are buried."
9. WORSHIPPED AS GOD AFTER HIS
DEATH BY HIS FOLLOWERS George El. Edzard, in his book Avoda Sara,
quotes the following words of the commentator on the Hilkoth Akum (V,3) of
Maimonides: "In many passages of the Talmud mention is made of Jesus the
Nazarene and of his disciples, and that the Gentiles believe that there is
no other God besides him. In the book Chizzuk Emunah, part I, ch. 36, we
read: "The Christians build up an argument from this [Zachary XII, 10] and
say: Behold how thew Prophet testified that in future ages the Jews would
would lament and weep because they crucified and killed the Messiah who was
sent to them; and to prove that he meant Jesus the Nazarene, possessing both
the divine and human nature, they quote the words: And they looked upon
him whom they transfixed and they wept over him as a mother over her
first born child."" Maimonides attempts to prove how much Christians err
in worshipping Jesus in his book Hilkoth Melakhim (IX, 4): "If all the
things he did had prospered, if he had rebuilt the Sanctuary in its place,
and had gathered together the dispersed tribes of Israel, then he would
certainly be the Messiah....But if so far hew has not done so and if he was
killed, then it is clear he was not the Messiah whom the Law tells us to
expect. He was similar to all the good and upright rulers of the House of
David who died, and whom the Holy and Blessed Lord raised up for no other
reason but to prove to many, as it is said (in Dan. XI, 35):And some of
them who understand shall fall, to try and to purge them and to make them
white, even till the end of time, because the appointed time is not
yet. Daniel also prophesised about Jesus the Nazarene who thought he was
the Christ, and who was put to death by the judgment of the Senate: (Dan.
V.14): ...and the robbers of thy people shall exalt themselves to
establish the vision; but they shall fail.
What could be plainer? For all the Prophets said
that the Christ would set Israel free, would bring it salvation, restore its
dispersed peoples and confirm their laws. But he was the cause of the
destruction of Israel and caused the rest of them to be dispersed and
humiliated, so that the Law was changed and the greater part of the world
was seduced to worship another God. Truly no one can understand the designs
of the Creator, nor are his ways our ways. For all that has been built up by
Jesus the Nazarene, and by the Turks who came after him, tend only to
prepare the way for the coming of Christ the King, and to prepare the whole
world equally for the service of the Lord, as it is said: For then I
shall give a clean moth to all peoples that all may call upon the
name of the Lord, and bow down in unison before him. How is this being
accomplished? Already the whole world is filled with the praise of Christ,
the Law and the Commandments, and his praises have spread to far distant
lands and to peoples whose hearts and bodies are uncircumcised. These
discuss with one another about the Law that was destroyed - some saying that
the commandments were once true, but have ceased to exist; others that there
is a great mystery about it, that the Messiah-King has come and that their
doctrine has revealed it. But when the Christ truly comes and is successful,
and is raised up and exalted, then everything will be changed and these
things will be shown to be false and vain."
10. AN IDOL In the
Tract Abhodah Zarah, (21a Toseph), we read: "It is of importance to inquire
the reasons why men nowadays even sell and rent their houses to Gentiles.
Some say this is legal because it is said in Tosephta: No one shall rent his
house to a gentile either here [in the land of Israel] or elsewhere because
it is known that he will bring an idol into it. It is nevertheless allowed
to rent them stables, barns and lodging houses, even though it is known that
they will bring idols into them. The reason is because a distinction can be
made between a place into which an idol will be carried in order to leave it
there permanently, and a place where it will not be left permanently, in
which case it is allowed. And since the gentiles, among whom we now live, do
not bring their idol into their homes to leave it there permanently, but
only for a time - while someone is dead in the house or when someone is
dying, nor do they even perform any religious rites there - it is therefore
permitted to sell and rent them houses." Rabbi Ascher, in his Commentary on
Abhodah Zarah (83d) speaks not less clearly on this matter: "Today it is
permitted to rent houses to Gentiles because they bring their idol into them
only for a time, when somebody is sick." And in the same place he says
"Today they have a practice of incensing their idol."" All this, and much
more like it, proves beyond a doubt that when the Rabbis speak of the idols
of the Gentiles among whom they lived at that time, when no idols were
worshipped, they clearly meant the Christian "idol," namely, the image of
Christ on the crucifix and the Holy Communion.
NOTE ABOUT THE CROSS
In Jewish writings there is no directly
corresponding word for the Christian Cross. The cross T on which those
condemned to death were crucified, was called Tau by the Phoenicians and the
Hebrews, and this name and sign for it was afterwards taken over into the
alphabet of the Jews and of the Greeks and the Romans. The Cross honored by
the Christians, however, is called
by the following names:
1. Tsurath Haattalui - the
image who was hanged.
2. Elil - vanity, idol.
3. Tselem - image. Hence the Crusaders in Jewish books are called Tsalmerim
(ein Tsalmer)
4. Scheti Veerebh - warp and woof, which is taken from the textile art.
5. Kokhabh - star; on account of the four rays emanating from it.
6. Pesila - a sculpture, a carven idol.
But whenever it is mentioned it is always in the
sense of an idol or of something despicable, as can be seen from the
following
quotations:
In Orach Chaiim, 113,8:
"If a Jew when praying should meet a Christian [Akum]
carrying a star [a crucifix] in his hand, even if he has come to a place in
his prayer where it is necessary to bow down to worship God in his heart, he
must not to so lest he should seem to bow down
before an image."
In Iore Dea, 150,2:
"Even if a Jew should get a splinter in his foot in
front of an idol, or if he should drop his money before it, he must not
stoop down to remove the splinter or to gather his money lest he should seem
to adore it. But he should either sit down or turn his back or his side to
the idol and then remove the splinter." But whenever it is not possible for
a Jew to turn away like this, the following rule must be observed (in Iore
Dea, 3, Hagah): "It is not permitted to bow down or to remove one's hat
before princes or priests who wear a cross on their dress, as is their
custom. Care must be taken, however, not to be noticed in failing to do so.
For instance, one can throw some coins on the ground and stoop down to pick
them up before they pass by. In this way it is permitted to bow down or to
remove one's hat before them." A distinction is also made between a cross
which is venerated and a cross which is worn around the neck as a souvenir
or as an ornament. The former is to be regarded as an idol, but not
necessarily the latter. In Iore Dea, 141, 1, Hagah, it says:
"The image of a cross, before which they bow down,
is to be treated as an idol, and it is not to be used until it is destroyed.
However, a 'warp and woof' if hung around the neck as a souvenir is not to
be regarded as an idol and can be used." The sign of the cross made with the
hand, by which Christians are wont to bless themselves, is called in Jewish
"the moving of the fingers here and there" (hinc et hinc).
Article III. - THE TEACHINGS OF
CHRIST
The Seducer and Idolator could teach nothing but
falsehood and heresy which was irrational and impossible to observe.
1. FALSHOOD In Abhodah
Zarah (6a) it says: "A Nazarene is one who follows the false teachings of
that man who taught them to worship on the first day of the Sabbath."
2. HERESY In the same
book Abohah Zar. (Ch.I, 17a Toseph) mention is made of the heresy of James.
A little further on (27b) we learn that this James was none other than the
disciple of Jesus: "...James Sekhanites, one of the disciples of Jesus, of
whom we spoke in chapter 1." But James taught, not his own doctrine, but
that of Jesus.
3. IMPOSSIBLE TO OBSERVE
The author of Nizzachon argues as follows on this point: "A written
law of the Christians is: If a Jew strike you on one cheek, turn the other
also to him and do not in any way return the blow. And ch. VI, v. 27 says:
Love your enemies; do good to them who hate you; bless them who curse you
and pray for those who do you harm; unto him who strikes you on one
cheek offer him the other. To him who takes away thy cloak do not
forbid him to take thy coat also, etc. The same is found in Matthew ch.
V, v.39. But I have never seen any Christian keep this law, nor did Jesus
himself behave as he taught others to do. For we find in John ch XVIII, v22,
that when someone struck him on the face, he did not turn the other cheek,
but became angry on account of this one stroke and asked "Why do you strike
me"? Likewise in the Acts of the Apostles, ch.XXIII, v. 3, we read: that
when the High Priest ordered them that stood by to strike him on the mouth,
Paul did not turn the other cheek; he cursed him saying "God shall smite
thee thou whited wall, etc." This is contrary to their beliefs and destroys
the foundation upon which their religion rests, for they boast that the law
of Jesus is easy to observe. If Paul himself, who may be called the
Dispenser of Jesus, could not preserve the precept of Jesus, who among the
others who believe in him can prove to me that he can do so?"
The author, however, who had the Gospels and the
Acts of the Apostles under his hand, could not have failed to understand in
what sense Christ commanded his followers to turn the other cheek to him who
would strike them, since in another place he commanded his followers to cut
off a hand or an arm, and to pluck out an eye if these should scandalize
them. No one who has had the least acquaintance with the Holy Scriptures
ever thought that these commands should be taken literally . Only deep
malice and ignorance of the times in which Jesus lived can explain why the
Jews, even to this day, use these passages to detract from the teachings of
Jesus Christ.
CHAPTER II
THE CHRISTIANS
There are three things to be considered in this
chapter:
1. The names by which Christians are called in the
Talmud.
2. What kind of people the Talmud pictures Christians to be.
3. What the Talmud says about the religious worship of the Christians.
Article I. - The Names Given to
Christians in the Talmud
As in our languages Christians take their name from
Christ, so in the language of the Talmud Christians are called Notsrim, from
Jesus the Nazarene. But Christians are also called by the names used in the
Talmud to designate all non-Jews: Abhodah Zarah, Akum, Obhde Elilim,
Minim, Nokhrim, Edom, Amme Haarets, Goim, Apikorosim, Kuthrim.
1. Abhodah Zarah
- Strange worship, idolatry. The Talmudic Tract on Idolatry is thus
entitled: Obhde Abhodah Zarah - Idol Worshippers. That Abhodah Zarah really
means the cult of idols is clear from the Talmud itself: "Let Nimrod come
and testify that Abraham was not a server of Abhodah Zarah ." But in these
days of Abraham there existed no strange cult either of the Turks or the
Nazarenes, but only the worship of the true God and idolatry. In Schabbath
(ibid. 82a), it says:
"Rabbi Akibah says: How do we know that Abhodah Zarah, like an unclean
woman, contaminates those who subscribe to it? Because Isaiah says: Thou
shalt cast them away like a menstruation cloth; and shalt say unto it, Get
thee hence." In the first part of this verse mention is made of idols made
from gold and silver. The learned Maimonides also clearly demonstrates that
the Jews regarded Christians as Abhodah Zarah. In Perusch(78c) he
says: "And be it known that Christian people who follow Jesus, although
their teachings vary, are all worshippers of idols (Abhodah Zarah)."
2. Akum - This
word is made up of the initial letters of the words Obhde Kokhabkim U
Mazzaloth - worshippers of stars and planets. It was thus that the Jews
formerly styled the Gentiles who lacked all knowledge of the true God. Now,
however, the word Akum in Jewish books, especially in the Schulkhan Arukh,
is applied to Christians. This is evident from numerous passages: In the
Orach Chaiim (113,8) those who use a cross are called Akum. In the Iore Dea
(148, 5, 12), those who celebrate the feasts of Christmas and New Year,
eight days afterwards, are called worshippers of the stars and planets:
"Thus if a gift is sent to the Akum, even in these times, on the eighth day
after Christmas, which they call the New Year," etc.
3. Obhde Elilim
- Servers of idols. This name has the same meaning as Akum. Non-Jews are
frequently called by this name. In the Orach Chaiim, for example (215, 5),
it says: "A blessing should not be pronounced over incense which belongs to
the servers of idols." But at the same time when the Schulkhan Arukh was
written there were no worshippers of the stars and planets (Akum); there
were no 'servers of idols' among those who lived with the Jews. Thus, for
example, the author of the Commentary on the Schulkhan Arukh (entitled Magen
Abraham), Rabbi Calissensis who died in Poland in 1775, in note 8, on No.
244 of the Orach Chaiim (where it is allowed to finish a work on the Sabbath
with the help of an Akum) says: "Here in our city the question is raised
about the price of hiring worshippers of the stars and planets who sweep the
public streets when they work on the Sabbath."
4.
Minim - Heretics. In the Talmud those who
possess books called the Gospels are heretics. Thus in Schabbath (116a) it
says: "Rabbi Meir calls the books of the Minim Aven Gilaion [iniquitous
volumes] because they call them Gospels."
5. Edom -
Edomites. Rabbi Aben Ezra, when he speaksabout the Emperor Constantine who
changed his religion and placed the image of him who was hanged on his
banner, adds: "Rome therefore is called the Kingdom of the Edomites." And
Rabbi Bechai, in his Kad Hakkemach (fol. 20a, on Isaiah, ch. LXVI, 17)
writes: "They are called Edomites who move their fingers 'here and there'"
(who make the sign of the cross). Likewise Rabbi Bechai, commenting on the
words of Isaiah (loc. cit.), "those who eat the flesh of swine" adds: "These
are the Edomites." Rabbi Kimchi, however, calls them "Christians." And Rabbi
Abarbinel, in his work Maschima Ieschua (36 d) says: "The Nazarenes are
Romans, the sons of Edom."
6. Goi - Race,
or people. The Jews also call a man a Goi - a gentile; they call a gentile
woman a Goiah. Sometimes, but very rarely, Israelites are called by this
name. It is mostly applied to non-Jews, or idolators. In Jewish books which
treat of Idolatry, worshippers of idols are often called by this single word
Goi. For this reason, in more recent editions of the Talmud the use of the
word Goi is purposely avoided and other words for non-Jews are substituted.
It is well known that in the Jewish language, the Jews call Christians among
whom they live, Goim. Nor do the Jews deny this.
Sometimes in their popular magazines they say that this word means nothing
harmful or evil. But the contrary can be seen in their books written in the
Hebrew language. For instance, in Choschen Hammischpat (34, 22), the name
Goi is used in a depraved sense: "Traitors and Epicureans and Apostates are
worse than Goim"
7. Nokhtrim -
strangers, foreigners. This name is used for all who are not Jews, and
therefor for Christians.
8.
Amme Haarets - People of the earth, idiots.
There are some who say that people of other races are not meant by this, but
only crude and uneducated people. There are passages, however, which leave
no doubt about the matter. In the Holy Scripture, Book of Esra, ch. X, 2, we
read: We have sinned against our God, and have taken strange wives [nokhrioth]
of the people of the earth. That people of the earth denotes
idolators is clear from Zohar, I, 25a: "The People of the earth -
Obhde
Abhodah Zarah, idolaters.
9.
Basar Vedam - Flesh and blood; carnal men
who are destined to perdition and who can have no communion with God. That
Christians are flesh and blood, is proved from the prayer book:
"Whoever meets a wise and educated Christian can say: Blessed art thou O
Lord, King of the Universe, who dispenseth of thy wisdom to Flesh and
Blood," etc. Likewise in another prayer, in which they ask God soon to
restore the kingdom of David and to send Elias and the Messia, etc., they
aak him to take away their poverty so that they will have no need to accept
gifts from "flesh and blood," nor to trade with them, nor to seek wages from
them.
10. Apikorosim -
Epicureans. All are called by this name who do not observe God's precepts,
as well as all those, even Jews themselves, who express private judgments in
matters of faith. How much more, therefore, Christians!
11.
Kuthim - Samaritans. But since there are no
longer any Samaritans, and since there are many references in recent Jewish
books to Samaritans, who can doubt that this does not mean the Christians?
Furthermore, in this matter of naming those who are not Jews, it is to be
particularly noted that Jewish writings apply these names indiscriminately
and promiscuously when they speak of the same thing, and almost in the same
words. For instance, in the Tract Abhodah Zarah (25b) the word Goi is
employed, but in the Schulkhan Arukh (Iore Dea 153, 2) Akum is
used. Kerithuth (6b) uses Goim; Jebhammoth (61a) uses
Akum; Abhodah Zar. (2a) uses Obhde Elilim; Thoseph uses
Goim and Obhde Ab., Choschen Ham (Venetian ed.) uses Kuthi;
(Slav. ed.) Akum. And many more instances could be quoted.
Maimonides in his book on Idolatry indiscriminately calls all the following
idolators: Goim, Akum, Obhde Kokhabhim, Obhde Elilim, etc.
Article II. - What the Talmud
Teaches About Christians
In the preceding chapter we saw what the Jews think
of the Founder of the Christian religion, and how much they despise his
name. This being so, it would not be expected that they would have any
better opinion about those who follow Jesus the Nazarene. In fact, nothing
more abominable can be imagined than what they have to say about Christians.
They say that they are idolaters, the worst kind of people, much worse than
the Turks, murderers, fornicators, impure animals, like dirt, unworthy to be
called men, beasts in human form, worthy of the name of beasts, cows, asses,
pigs, dogs, worse than dogs; that they propagate after the manner of beasts,
that they have diabolic origin, that their souls come from the devil and
return to the devil in hell after death; and that even the body of a dead
Christian is nothing different from that of an animal.
1. IDOLATERS Since
Christians follow the teachings of that man, whom the Jews regard as
a Seducer and an Idolater, and since they worship him as God, it clearly
follows that they merit the name of idolater, in no way different from those
among whom the Jews lived before the birth of Christ, and whom they taught
should be exterminated by every possible means.
This is best demonstrated by the names they give
Christians, and by the unmistakable words of Maimonides which prove that all
who bear the name of Christian are idolaters. And anyone who examines Jewish
books which speak of the "Worshippers of the Stars and Planets,"
"Epicureans," "Samaritans," etc., cannot but conclude that these idolaters
are none other than Christians.
The Turks are always called "Ismaelites," never idolaters.
2. CHRISTIANS WORSE THAN THE
TURKS Maimonides in Hilkoth Maakhaloth (ch. IX) says: "It is
not permitted to drink the wine of a stranger who becomes a convert, that
is, one who accepts the seven precepts of Noah, but is permitted to gain
some benefit from it. It is allowed to leave wine alone with him, but not to
place it before him. The same is permitted in the case of all gentiles who
are not idolaters, such as the Turks [Ismaelites]. A Jew, however, is not
permitted to drink their wine, although he may use it to his own advantage."
3. MURDERERS In
Abhodah Zarah (22a) it says: "A Jew must not associate himself with
gentiles because they are given to the shedding of blood." Likewise in
Iore Dea (153, 2): "An Israelite must not associate himself with the
Akum [Christians] because they are given to the shedding of blood." In the
Abhodah Zarah (25b) it says: "The Rabbis taught: If a Goi joins an
Israelite on the road, he [the Jew] should walk on his right side. Rabbi
Ismael, the son of Rabbi Jochanan the nephew of Beruka, says: if he carries
a sword, let the Jew walk on his right side. If the Goi carries a stick, the
Jew should walk on his left side. If he is climbing a hill or descending a
steep incline, the Jew must not go in front with the Goi behind, but the Jew
must go behind and the Goi in front, nor must he stoop down in front of him
for fear the Goi might crack his skull. And if he should ask the Jew how far
he is going, he should pretend he is going a long way, as Jacob our Father
said to the impious Esau: until I come to my Lord in Seir (Gen. XXXIII,
14-17), but it adds: Jacob set out for Sukoth."
In Orach Chaiim (20, 2) it says: "Do not sell
your overcoat (Talith) with the fringes to an Akum, lest he should
join up with a Jew on the road and kill him. It is also forbidden to
exchange or lend your overcoat with a Gentile, except for a short time and
when there is nothing to be feared from him."
4. FORNICATORS In the
Abhodah Zarah (15b) it says: "Animals of the masculine sex must not
be left in the barns of the Gentiles with their men, nor animals of the
feminine sex with their women; much less must animals of the feminine sex be
left with their men and of the masculine sex with their women. Nor must
sheep be left to the care of their shepherds; nor must any intercourse be
had with them; nor must children be given into their care to learn to read
or to learn a trade." In the same tract a little farther on (22a) it is
explained why animals must not be allowed in the barns of Gentiles, and why
Jews are not permitted to have sexual intercourse with them: "Animals must
not be allowed to go near the Goim, because they are suspected of having
intercourse with them. Nor must women cohabit with them because they are
over-sexed. "In fol. 22b of the same book the reason is given why animals
especially of the feminine sex must be kept away from their women:
"...because when Gentile men come to their neighbors' houses to commit
adultery with their wives and do not find them at home, they fornicate with
the sheep in the barns instead. And sometimes even when their neighbors'
wives are at home, they prefer to fornicate with the animals; for they love
the sheep of the Israelites more than their own women." It is for the same
reason that animals are not to be entrusted to Goi shepherds, nor children
to their educators.
5. UNCLEAN The Talmud
gives two reasons why the Goim are unclean: because they eat unclean things,
and because they themselves have not been cleansed (from original sin) on
Mount Sinai. In Schabbath, (145b) it says: "Why are the Goim unclean?
Because they eat abominable things and animals that crawl on their belly."
Likewise in Abhodah Zarah, 22b: "Why are the Goim unclean? Because
they were not present at Mount Sinai. For when the serpent entered into Eve
he infused her with uncleanness. But the Jews were cleansed from this when
they stood on Mount Sinai; the Goim, however, who were not on Mount Sinaim
were not cleansed."
6. COMPARED TO DUNG
"When ten persons are praying together in one place and they say Kaddisch,
or Kedoschah, anyone, even though he does not belong there, may
respond Amen. There are some, however, who say that no dung or Akum must be
present." In Iore Dea (198, 48) Hagah, it says: "When Jewish
women come out of a bath they must take care to meet a friend first, and not
something unclean or a Chrsitian. For if so, a woman, if she wants to keep
holy, should go back and bathe again." It is worthy of note that the
following list of unclean things is a given in Biur Hetib, a
commentary on the Schulchan Arukh: "A woman must wash herself again
if she sees any unclean things, such as a dog, an ass, or People of the
Earth; a Christian (Akum), a camel, a pig, a horse, and a leper.
7. NOT LIKE MEN, BUT BEASTS
In Kerithuth (6b p. 78) it says: "The teaching of the Rabbis is: He who
pours oil over a Goi, and over dead bodies is freed from punishment. This is
true for an animal because it is not a man. But how can it be said that by
pouring oil over a Goi one is freed from punishment, since a Goi is also a
man? But this is not true, for it is written: Ye are my flock, the flock
of my pasture are men (Ezechiel, XXXIV, 31). You are thus called men,
but the Goim are not called men." In the Tract Makkoth (7b) he is said to be
guilty of killing "except when, if intending to kill an animal he kills a
man by mistake, or intending to kill a Goi, he kills an Israelite." In
Orach Chaiim (225, 10) it says: "He who sees beautiful creatures, even
though it be an Akum or an animal, let him say 'Blessed art thou Our Lord
God, King of the Universe, who has placed such things on the earth!'"
8. THEY DIFFER ONLY IN FORM
FROM BEASTS In Midrasch Talpioth (fol. 225d) it says: "God created
them in the form of men for the glory of Israel. But Akum were created for
the sole end of ministering unto them [the Jews] day and night. Nor can they
ever be relieved from this service. It is becoming to the son of a king [an
Israelite] that animals in their natural form, and animals in the form of
human beings should minister unto him." We can quote here also what is said
in Orach Chaiim, 57, 6a: "If pigs are to be pitied when they suffer
from disease, because their intestines are similar to ours, how much more
should the Akum be pitied when thus affected."
9. ANIMALS In Zohar,
II, (64b) it says: "...People who worship idols, and who are called cow and
ass, as it is written: I have a cow and an ass..." Rabbi Bechai, in his book
Kad Hakkemach, ch. I, beginning with the word Geulah - redemption -
referring to Psalm 80, v.13: The boar out of the wood doth waste it,
says: "The letter ain is dropped [suspended] the same as these worshippers
are followers of him who was suspended." Buxtorf (Lex.) says: "By wild pig
the author here means the Christians who eat pork and, like pigs, have
destroyed the vineyard of Israel, the City of Jerusalem, and who believe in
the 'suspended' Christ. Else the letter ain is dropped in this word because
they, as worshippers of Christ who was hanged, are also dropped." Rabbi
Edels, in commenting on Kethuboth (110b) says: "The Psalmist compares
the Akum to the unclean beast in the woods."
10. WORSE THAN ANIMALS
Rabbi Schelomo Iarchi (Raschi), famous Jewish commentator, explaining the
law of Moses (Deuter. XIV, 21) forbidding the eating of meat of wounded
animals, but which must be given to the 'stranger in thy gates,' or which,
according to Exodus (XXII, 30) is to be thrown to the dogs, has this to say:
"...for he is like a dog. Are we to take to word 'dog' here literally? By no
means. For the text in speaking of dead bodies says, Or thou mayest sell
it to an alien. This applies much more to the meat of wounded animals,
for which it is permitted to accept payment. Why therefore does the
Scripture say it may be thrown to 'dogs?' In order to teach you that a dog
is to be more respected than the Nokhri."
11. THEY PROPAGATE LIKE BEASTS
In the Sanhedrin (74b) Tosephoth, it says: "The sexual intercourse of a Goi
is like that of a beast." And in Kethuboth (3b) it says: "The seed of a Goi
is worth the same as that of a beast." Hence it is to be inferred that
Christian marriage is not true marriage. In Kidduschim (68a), it says:
"...How do we know this? Rabbi Huna says: You can read: Remain here with the
ass, that is, with a people like an ass. Hence it appears that they are not
capable of contracting marriage." And in Eben Haezer (44, 8): "If a Jew
enters into marriage with an Akum (Christian), or with his servant, the
marriage is null. For they are not capable of entering into matrimony.
Likewise if an Akum or a servant enter into matrimony with a Jew, the
marriage is null." In Zohar (II, 64b) it says: "Rabbi Abba says: If only
idolaters alone had sexual intercourse, the world would not continue to
exist. Hence we are taught that a Jew should not give way to those infamous
robbers. For if these propagate in greater numbers, it will be impossible
for us to continue to exist because of them. For they give birth to
sucklings the same as dogs."
12. CHILDREN OF THE DEVIL
In Zohar (I, 28b) we read: "Now the serpent was more subtle than any
beast of the field, etc. (Genes. III, 1.) 'More subtle' that is towards
evil; 'than all beasts' that is, the idolatrous people of the earth. For
they are the children of the ancient serpent which seduced Eve." The best
argument used by the Jews to prove that Christians are of the race of the
devil is the fact that they are uncircumcised. The foreskin on non-Jews
prevents them from being called the children of the Most High God. For by
circumcision the name of God - Schaddai - is complete in the flesh of a
circumcised Jew. The form of the letter Isch is in his nostrils, the letter
Daleth in his (bent) arm, and ain appears in his sexual organ by
circumcision. In non-circumcised gentiles, therefore, such as Christians,
there are only two letters, Isch and Daleth, which make the word Sched,
which means devil. They are, therefore, children of the Sched, the devil.
13. THE SOULS OF CHRISTIANS
ARE EVIL AND UNCLEAN The teaching of the Jews is that God created two
natures, one good and the other evil, or one nature with two sides, one
clean and the other unclean. From the unclean side, called Keliphah - rind,
or scabby crust - the souls of Christians are said to have come. In Zohar
(I, 131a) it says: "idolatrous people, however, since they exist, befoul the
world, because their souls come out of the unclean side." And in Emek
Hammelech (23d) it says: "The souls of the impious come from Keliphah, which
is death and the shadows of death." Zohar (I, 46b, 47a) goes to show that
this unclean side is the left side, from which the souls of the Christians
come: "And he created every living thing, that is, the Israelites, because
they are the children of the Most High God, and their holy souls come out
from Him. But where do the souls of the idolatrous gentiles come from? Rabbi
Eliezer says: from the left side, which makes their souls unclean. They are
therefore all unclean and they pollute all who come in contact with them."
14. AFTER DEATH THEY GO DOWN
TO HELL The Elders teach that Abraham sits at the gate of Gehenna and
prevents any circumcized person from entering there; but that all the
uncircumcised go down to hell. In Rosch Haschanach (17a) it says: "Heretics
and Epicureans and Traitors go down into hell."
15. THE FATE OF DEAD
CHRISTIANS The bodies of Christians after death are called by the
odious name of Pegarim, which is the word used in Holy Scripture for the
dead bodies of the damned and of animals, but never for the pious dead who
are called Metim. Thus the Schulchan Arukh orders that a dead Christian must
be spoken of in the same way as a dead animal. In Iore Dear (377, 1) it
says: "Condolences must not be offered to anyone on account of the death of
his servants or handmaids. All that may be said is 'May God restore your
lost one, the same as we say to a man who has lost a cow or an ass.'" Nor
must Christians be avoided for seven days after they have buried someone,
as the law of Moses commands, since they are not men; for the burial of an
animal does not pollute one. In Iebhammoth (61a) it says: "The Nokhrim are
not rendered unclean by a burial. For it is said: Ye are my sheep, the
sheep of my pasture; ye are men. You are thus called men, but not the
Nokhrim."
Article III. - About Christian Rites
and Worship
Since Christians are regarded by the Jews as
idolators, all their forms of worship are idolatrous. Their priests are
called priests of Baal; their temples are called houses of lies and
idolatry, and everything they contain, such as chalices, statues and books,
are regarded as made for the serving of idols; their prayers, both private
and public, are sinful and offensive to God; and their
festivals are called days of evil.
1. PRIESTS The Talmud
speaks of priests, the ministers of Christian worship, as idolatrous and
belonging to the god Baal. They are also called Komarim -
Soothsayers; and also Galachim, the shaved, because they shave their
heads, particularly the monks. In Abhodah Zarah (14b) Toseph,
it says: "It is forbidden to sell books of the prophets to the soothsayers,
since they may use them for their evil worship in their idolatrous temples.
Those who do so sin against the law which forbids us to place an obstacle in
the way of a blind person. It is also forbidden to sell them to a Christian
who is not shaved, for he is sure to give or sell them to one of them who is
shaved."
2. CHRISTIAN CHURCHES A
place of Christian worship is called (1) Beth Tilfah, a house of
vanity and foolishness, in place of Beth Tefilah, a house of prayer;
(2) Beth Abhodha Zarah, a House of Idolatry; (3) Beth Hatturapi
Schel Letsim, a house of Evil Laughter. In Abhodah Zarah (78) the
Perusch of Maimonides, it says: "Be it known to you that it is beyond a
doubt forbidden by law to pass through a Christian city in which there is a
house of vanity, that is, a house of idolatry; much more to live therein.
But we today, as punishment for our sins, are subject to them, and are
forced to live in their countries, as it was foretold in Deuteronomy
(IV, 28): And there ye shall serve gods, the work of men's hands,
of wood and stone...Thus if it is allowed as predicted to pass around a
Christian city, much more so must we pass around an idolatrous temple; nor
is it allowed us even to look inside and above all to enter in." A Jew is
forbidden not only to enter a Christian church, but even to go near it,
except under certain circumstances. In Iore Dea (142, 10) it says: "It is
forbidden to stand in the shadow of a house of idolatry, whether from the
inside or the outside, for a distance of four cubits from the front door. It
is not forbidden, however, to stand under the shadows of the back of a
church. Nor is the shadow forbidden us if the church stands in a place where
formerly there was public road, which was taken from the community and the
house of idolatry built upon it. For the road is still there. But if the
house of idolatry existed before the road, it is not permitted to pass
before it. There are some who say that it is forbidden to pass there in any
case." Neither is a Jew allowed to listen to, or admire the beautiful music
of the churches. In Iore Dea (142, 15) it says: "It is forbidden to listen
to the music if idolatrous worship, and to examine the statues of their
idols; for even by looking at them one can be influenced by the evil of
idolatry. But one can look who does not intend to be so affected." Likewise
a Jew is not allowed to have a house near a church; nor is he allowed to
rebuild a house which has been destroyed in such a place. In Iore Dea (143,
1) it says: "If a house near an idolatrous temple belonging to the Akum
falls down, it must not be rebuilt. A Jew must remove it a certain distance
away if he wishes to rebuild it. But he must fill up the vacant space
between his house and the church with bushes and rubbish so that the space
will not be used to extend the idolatrous temple."
Here may be added what a certain Rabbi Kelomimus
said about a Christian church (in the book Nizzachon) to the Emperor Henry
III, who gave him permission to speak his opinion freely about the Basilica
which he had recently built at Spires: "After the Emperor Henry III, a very
wicked man, had completed the building of that "Abyss," he sent for Rabbi
Kelominus and said to him: "I want to ask you, how does this Basilica which
I have built compare with the magnificence of Solomon's
Temple, about which so many volumes have been written?" He replied: 'My
Lord, if you will permit me that you will let me go unharmed, I will tell
you the truth about it.' The Emperor answered: 'I give you my word as a
lover of the truth and as an Emperor, that no harm shall come to you.' Then
the Jew said: 'If you gathered together all you have spent so far, and added
to it all the silver and gold in your treasury, it would not suffice even to
pay the workmen and craftsmen that Solomon employed; for it is written (Chron.
II, ch 2): And Solomon told out threescore and ten thousand men to bear
burdens, and fourscore thousand to hew in the mountains, and three
thousand and six hundred to oversee them. Eight years were spent in the
building of the Temple, much more than you spent in building this Tehon
[Abyss]. And when Solomon had finished his Temple,
see what the Scripture says about it: The priests could not stand to
minister by reason of the cloud; for the glory of God had filled the
House of the Lord (Chron. II, Ch. 5, 14). But if someone loaded an ass
with putrid garbage and led it into this abyss of yours, no one would notice
the difference!' The Emperor Henry then replied: 'Were it not that I have
sworn to let you go unharmed, I would order your head cut off.'"
3. CHALICES Chalises
used in the Sacrifice of the mass are spoken of as vessels in which filth is
offered up to the idol. Moses Kozzensis, in Hilkoth Abhodah Zarah
(10b) says: "A Jew who buys Chalises of the Goi, which are broken and thrown
away, it is not permitted to sell them again to them, because their priest
of Baal will use them in the worship of the idol."
4. BOOKS The Talmud
calls the books of the Christians Minim - heretical books - Siphre
Debeth Abidan - Books of the House of Perdition. The Talmud in
particular speaks of the books of the Gospels. Thus in Schabbath
(116a) Toseph: "Rabbi Meir calls heretical books Aaven Gilaion
(volumes of iniquity) because the call them Gospels." And Rabbi Jochanan
calls these books Aavon Gilaion, evil books. The Schulchan Arukh,
Crakow edition, gives this name as Aven Niktabh al Haggilaion - iniquity
written in a book. Buxtorf says: "In the Arukh there is a note Scheker
Niktabh al Gilaion, which means, a lie written in a book." All the
Talmudists agree that the books of the Christians should be destroyed. They
differ only as to what should be done with the names of God contained in
them. In Schabbath (116a) it says: "The Glossaries of our own books
and the books of the heretics are not to be saved from the flames, if they
should catch fire on the Sabbath day. Rabbi Jose, however, says: 'On
festival days the divine names should be torn out of the books of the
Christians and hidden away; what remains must be given to the flames.' But
Rabbi Tarphon says: 'In order that I may be remembered by my children, if
those books should ever fall into my hands I would burn them together with
the divine names contained therein. For if one is chased by an assassin, or
by a serpent, it would be better to take refuge in a pagan temple than in
one of theirs; because the Christians knowingly resist the truth, whereas
the pagans do so unknowingly."
5. PRAYERS Christian
prayers are called, not Tefillah, but Tiflah. They change the
point and insert Iod, which makes it read to mean sin, foolishness
and transgression.
6. CHRISTIAN FESTIVALS
Christian festivals, especially Sunday, are called Ion Ed - day of
destruction, perdition, misfortune or calamity. They are also simply called
Iom Notsri - Christian Days. The word Ed rightly interpreted
means misfortune or calamity, as appears from the Gemarah and the
Glossaries of Maimonides in Abhodah Zarah (2a): "The word Edehem
means the festivals of the Christians, since it is written (in Deuter.
XXXII, 35): the day of their calamity." Maimonides also says in
Abhodah Zarah (78c): "The words Edehem means the foolishness of
their festivlas. It is the name for their despicable feast days which do not
merit the name of Moedim, for they are really vain and evil."
Baretenora also writes: "The word Edehem is the name for their
ignominious festivals and solemnities." The marginal notes of Tosephtoth
also give this name to Christian festivals. Thus in Abhodah Zarah
(6a): "The Day of Evil, that is the Christian Day, is forbidden to us as
well as all their other feast days." Some Christian festivals are mentioned
by name, such as the feast of Christmas and Easter. Moses Mikkozzi,
referring to the above text of Abhodah Zarah , says: "Rabbi Sammuel
declares, in the name of Solomon Iarchi, that in particular the festivals of
Christmas and Easter, which are their principal evil days and the
foundation of their religion, are forbidden to us." Maimonides, in
hilkoth Akum (ch. IX) has the same: "Sammuel repeats the words of Rabbi
Sal. Iarchi which forbid us particularly to celebrate the feasts of
Christmas and Easter, which are celebrated on account of him who was
hanged." Furthermore, indications of the impiety of the Jews are to be found
in the names which they give to these Christian festivals: For in place of
using Tau in the word Nithal, they often write Tet and call it Nital for the
Latin word Natalis, the Feast of the Nativity. They make it appear as if
this word were from the root Natal which connotes extermination or
destruction. Likewise they refuse to use the word Paschal (Pesach) for the
Christian feast of Easter. The substitute Koph for Phe and insert the letter
iod and call it Ketsach or Kesach. Both pronunciations have an evil meaning.
Ketsach is from the root Katsah, meaning to amputate or cut off from, and
Kesach is from the root Kesa, meaning to wood or a gallows. This is done
because the feast of Easter is celebrated by Christians in memory of Christ
- the one who was hanged - who was put to death and who rose again
from the dead.
PART TWO
PRECEPTS OF THE TALMUD
CONCERNING CHRISTIANS
From what has been shown thus far, it is clear that,
according to the teaching of the Talmud,
Christians are idolaters and hateful to Jews. As a consequence, every Jew
who wishes to please God has a duty to observe all the precepts which were
given to the Fathers of their race when they lived in the Holy Land
concerning the idolatrous gentiles, both those who lived amongst them and
those in nearby countries. A Jew is therefore required to
(1) To avoid Christians;
(2) To do all he can to exterminate them.
CHAPTER I
CHRISTIANS MUST BE AVOIDED
Jews are required to avoid all contact with
Christians for four reasons: (1) Because they are not worthy to share in the
Jewish way of life; (2) Because they are unclean; (3) Because they are
idolators; (4) Because they are murderers.
Article I. - Christians Must Be Avoided - Because
They Are Unworthy to Share Jewish Customs A Jew, by the fact that he belongs
to the chosen people and is circumcised, possesses so great a dignity that
no one, not even an angel, can share equality with him. In fact, he is
considered almost the equal of God. "He who strikes an Israelite" says Rabbi
Chanina "acts as if he slaps the face of God's Divine Majesty." A Jew is
always considered good, in spite of certain sins which he may commit; nor
can his sins contaminate him, any more than dirt contaminates the kernel in
a nut, but only soils its shell. A Jew alone is looked upon as a man; the
whole world is his and all things should serve him, especially "animals
which have the form of men." Thus it is plain that they regard all contact
with Christians as contaminating and as detracting from their dignity. They
are therefore required to keep as far away as possible from all who live and
act as Christians do.
1. A JEW MUST NOT SALUTE A
CHRISTIAN In Gittin (62a) it says: "A Jew must not enter the home of
a Nokhri on a feast day to offer him greetings. However, if he meets him on
the street,
he may offer him a greeting, but curtly and with head bowed."
2. A JEW MUST NOT RETURN THE
GREETINGS OF A CHRISTIAN In Iore Dea (148, 10) it says:
"A Jew must not return the greeting of a Christian by bowing before him. It
is good, therefore, to salute him first and so avoid having to answer him
back if the Akum salutes him first."
Rabbi Kohana says that when a Jew salutes a Christian he should say "Peace
to my Lord," but intend this for his own Rabbi. For the Tosephtoth says:
"For his heart was turned towards his own Rabbi."
3. A JEW MUST NOT GO BEFORE A
CHRISTIAN JUDGE In Choschen Hammischpat (26,1) it says:
"A Jew is not permitted to bring his case before Akum judges, even if the
matter is judged by the decisions of Jewish law, and even if both parties
agree to abide by such decisions. He who does so is impious and similar to
one who calumniates and blasphemes, and who raises his hand against the Law
given us by Moses, our great law-giver. Hagah says 'The Bethin has the power
to excommunicate such a one until he releases his Jewish brother from the
hands of the Gentile.'"
4. A CHRISTIAN CANNOT BE USED
AS A WITNESS In Choschen Ham. (34, 19) it says: "A Goi or a servant
is not capable of acting as a witness."
5. A JEW CANNOT EAT CHRISTIAN
FOOD In Iore Dea (112, 1) it says: "The Elders forbade the eating of
the bread of the Akum, lest we would seem to be familiar with them." And in
Abhodah arah (35b) it says: "The following things belonging to the Goim are
forbidden: Milk which a Goi takes from a cow, in the absence of a Jew; also
their bread, etc."
6. A JEW MUST NEVER ACT IN ANY
WAY LIKE A CHRISTIAN In Iore Dea (178, 1) it says:
"It is not permitted to imitate the customs of the Akum, nor to act like
them. Nor is it permitted to wear clothes like the Akum, not to comb the
hair as they do...neither must Jews build houses that look like temples of
the Akum." Since, however, it is not possible to observe all these rules in
every place, the Hagah says that they can be overlooked to a certain extent
when, for instance, it is to the advantage of the Jew to do so; for example,
if a Jew would profit by a trade which requires a certain kind of dress.
Article II. - Christians Are to
Be Avoided - Because They Are Unclean
It is not known how often Jews must wash and purify
themselves, nor how much they must study to avoid everything which might
render them unclean. The Talmud teaches, however, that Christians are people
whose touch alone makes things unclean. In Abhodah Zarah (72b) it says:
"A certain man was pouring wine from one jar into another by means of a
tube, when a Goi came along and touched the tube with his hand. As a result
all the wine (in both jars) had to be thrown away." Every vessel, therefore,
must be washed which comes into the possession of a Jew from a Christian,
although it has never been in use. In Iore Dea (120, 1) it says: "If a Jew
buys a vessel for use at table from an Akum, whether it is made of metal,
glass or lead, even if it is new, he must wash it in a Mikvah [a large
basin], or in a cistern which holds forty quarts of water.
Article III. - Christians Are to
Be Avoided - Because They Are Idolaters
1. Lest a Jew be the occasion of sin to the
idolatrous Christians, according to the precept in Levit. XIX, 14: "Do not
put a stumbling-block before the blind - he must avoid all contact with them
on the days when they worship their gods. In Abhodah Zarah (2a) it says:
"For three days before their idolatrous festivals it is not permitted to buy
or sell them anything. It is also forbidden to give
or take any help from them, to change any money with them, to pay them back
any debts or allow them to pay back debts." In the Abhodah Zarah, 78c (the
Perusch of Maimonides, fol. 8) it says:
"All the festivals of the followers of Jesus are forbidden, and we must
conduct ourselves towards them as we would towards idolators. The first day
of the week is their principal feast, and it is therefore forbidden to do
any business whatsoever with those who believe in Jesus on their Sabbath. We
must observe the same rules on their Sabbath as we do on the feastdays of
idolators, as the Talmud teaches."
2. A JEW MUST NOT USE ANYTHING
WHICH PERTAINS TO THE WORSHIP OF CHRISTIANS In Iore Dea (139, 1) it
says: "It is forbidden to have anything to do with idols and everything that
is used in their form of worship, whether they are made by the Akum or by
Jews."
3. IT IS FORBIDDEN TO SELL TO CHRISTIANS ANYTHING
CONNECTED WITH THEIR IDOLATROUS
WORSHIP The Abhodah Zarah (14b, Toseph) says:
"It is always forbidden to sell incense to an
idolatrous priest, for it is evident that when he asks for it he wants it
for no other purpose but to offer it before his idol. Anyone, therefore, who
would sell it to him sins against the precept which forbids us to place a
stumbling-block before the blind. It is also forbidden to sell candles to
gentiles for their Feat of Candles. Candles however may be sold to them on
other days. Neither is it permitted to sell a chalice to a gentile which a
Jew has
bought after a Goi has broken it and thrown it away. It may only be sold
again to a gentile after it has been completely made over. For after it has
been broken just once it can be used still to hold the wine which is offered
in honor of their idol." Then follows the prohibition as to the selling of
books to Christian priests, as we have seen above. Even the work of binding
such
books is forbidden to a Jew. In Iore Dea (139, 15) it says: "It is forbidden
to bind the books of the Akum, with the exception of law books. It may be
done, however, if refusal to do so should cause enmity, but only after every
effort has been made to refuse such work."
Likewise in Iore Dea (151, 1, Hagah): "It is not
permitted to sell water to an Akum if it is known that it will be made into
Baptismal water." Mention is also made of many other things which it is
forbidden to sell to Christians, such as: cloth from which priestly
vestments and banners may be made; paper and ink which may be used for
writing books pertaining to their divine worship. It is forbidden to sell,
or even to rent, houses to Christians which will be used by them as a place
of worship. Nowadays, however, Jews trade with Christians, especially on
Christian feast days, and also sell them houses knowing full well that
certain Sacraments will be administered therein, such as Baptism, Holy
Communion and Extreme Unction. The Talmud can give no reason for this, and
in the Abhodah Zarah (2a, Toseph) it says: "It is difficult to say by what
right Jews nowadays trade with the Goim on their (evil) feast days. For
although many of them commit all kinds of licentious acts and perversions on
their feast days in honor of saints which they do not look upon as gods, yet
every week they celebrate the Day of the Nazarene [Sunday] which has always
been forbidden to us." Bartenora, however, in his commentary on Abhodah
Zarah (I, 2, fol. 7b) it says: "Since, while we are in captivity, we cannot
live without trading with them, and we depend upon them for our food and we
must fear them, it is only forbidden to trade with them on their feast days.
Furthermore, it is permitted nowadays to trade with them on the actual day
of their feasts, because the Rabbis are convinced that they do not worship
their idols just because they trade with us. And what is forbidden in this
book must be taken as applying directly to idolatry." Rabbi Tam, however,
contends that the Mischnah only forbids the selling of things to idolaters
which will be used by them in the worship of idols, since they rejoice and
worship their idols because they obtain the things necessary for that
worship. He explains it thus (in Abhodah Zarah, 2a, Toseph):
"No one should wonder at this custom of ours. For, although we look upon
them as idolaters, they can only offer up what they buy for money. Hence,
our gain and their joy is not the reason for this prohibition, for they have
enough money for these things, even if we did not trade with them."
4. THIS PROHIBITION DOES NOT
APPLY TO ATHEISTS In Iore Dea (148, 5) it says: "It is only permitted
to send a gift to an Akum on one of their feast days if it is known that he
does not believe in idols and does not worship them." Maimonides has the
same in Hilkhoth Akum (IX, 2): "It is also wrong to send a gift to a Goi on
their feast days unless it is certain that he does not believe in the
worship of Christian idols, and does not serve them."
Article IV. - Christians Are to
Be Avoided - Because They Are Evil
There is nothing that Jews are more convinced of
than the harm which Christians can do to the children of Israel. Because of
this, the rulers of the Chosen People have always instructed them not to
accept any help from Christians who will always resort to murder, and to
other crimes, whenever they cannot otherwise obtain their evil ends. Thus a
Jew must not employ a Christian as a nurse, or as a teacher for his
children, or as a doctor, a barber or an obstetrician.
1. NOT AS A NURSE In
Iore Dea (81, 7, Hagah) it says: "A child must not be nursed by a Nokhri, if
an Israelite can be had; for the milk of the Nokhrith hardens the heart of a
child and builds up an evil nature in him."
2. NOT AS A TEACHER In
Iore Dea (153, 1, Hagah) it says: "A child must not be given to the Akum to
learn manners, literature or the arts, for they will lead him to heresy."
3. NOT AS A DOCTOR In
Iore Dea (155, 1) it says: "When a Jew is wounded in any way, even so
gravely that he would have to violate the Sabbath in having a doctor, he
must not employ the services of a Christian (Akum) doctor who is not known
to everyone in the neighborhood; for we
must guard against the spilling of blood. Even when it is not known if the
patient will live or die, such a doctor must not be allowed to attend him.
If, however, he is sure to die, then such a doctor may attend him, since an
extra hour of life is not much to lose. If the Akum insists that a certain
medicine is good, you may believe him, but be sure not to buy it from him.
There are some who say that this holds only when the Akum offer help free,
and that it can be accepted every time
it is paid for. But it can be taken for granted that they would not harm a
Jew just for the sake of a matter of money." In Pesachim (25a) it says:
"Rabbi Jochanan says: medical help can be accepted from all except
idolaters, fornicators and murderers."
4. NOT AS A BARBER In
Iore Dea (156,1 ) it says: "You must not be shaven by an Akum unless your
Jewish friends are with you. There are some who say that it is not permitted
to be shaved by an Akum even when others are present, unless you can see
yourself in a mirror."
5. NOT AS AN OBSTETRICIAN
In Abhodah Zarah (26a) it says: "Our Rabbis have passed it down for us, that
a foreign woman must never be allowed to act as midwife at the birth of a
child of Israel, because they are given to the shedding of blood. The Elders
say, however, that a foreign woman may perfrom this task provided there are
other Jewish women present, but never alone. Rabbi Meir, however, says that
it is not allowed even others are present. For they often crush the soft
head of the child with their hands and kill it; and they can do this without
being noticed by those who are present."
CHAPTER II
CHRISTIANS MUST BE EXTERMINATED
The followers of "that man," whose name is taken by
the Jews to mean "May his name and memory be blotted out," are not otherwise
to be regarded than as people whom it would be good to get rid of. They are
called Romans and tyrants who hold captive the children of Israel, and by
their destruction the Jews would be freed from this Fourth Captivity. Every
Jew is therefore bound to do all he can to destroy that impious kingdom of
the Edomites (Rome) which rules the whole world. Since, however, it is not
always and everywhere possible to effect this extermination of Christians,
the Talmud orders that they should be attacked at least indirectly, namely:
by injuring them in every possible way, and by thus lessening their power,
help towards their ultimate destruction. Wherever it is possible a Jew
should kill Christians, and do so without
mercy.
Article I. - HARM MUST BE DONE TO
CHRISTIANS
A Jew is commanded to harm Christians wherever he
can, both indirectly by not helping them in any way, and also directly
by wrecking their plans and projects; neither must he save a Christian who
is in danger of death.
I. GOOD MUST NOT BE DONE TO
CHRISTIANS In Zohar (1, 25b) it says: "Those who do good to the Akum...will
not rise from the dead." At times it is permitted to do good to Christians,
but only in order to help Israel, namely, for the sake of peace and to hide
hatred of them. Maimonides in Hilkhoth Akum (X, 6) says: "Needy Gentiles may
be helped as well as needy Jews, for the sake of peace..." In Iore Dea (148,
12 Hagah) it says: "Therefore if you enter a town and find them celebrating
a feast, you may pretend to rejoice with them in order to hide your hatred.
Those, however, who care about the salvation of their souls should keep away
from such celebrations.
You should make it known that it is a hateful thing to rejoice with them, if
you can do so without incurring enmity."
1. IT IS NOT PERMITTED TO
PRAISE A CHRISTIAN In Abhodah Zarah (20, a, Toseph) it says:
"Do not say anything in praise of them, lest it be said: How good that Goi
is!" In this way they explain the words of Deuteronomy (VII, 2)... and
thou shalt show no mercy unto them [Goim], as cited in the Gemarah.
Rabbi S. Iarchi explains this Bible passage as follows: "Do not pay them any
compliments; for it is forbidden to say: how good that Goi is." In Iore Dea
(151, 14) it says:
"No one is allowed to praise them or to say how good an Akum is. How much
less to praise what they do or to recount anything about them which would
redound to their glory. If, however, while praising them you intend to give
glory to God, namely, because he has created comely creatures, then it is
allowed to do so."
2. A JEW NOT ALLOWED TO
MENTION THE THINGS WHICH CHRISTIANS USE FOR THEIR
IDOLATROUS WORSHIP In Hilkhoth Akum (V, 12) it says: "It is also
forbidden to make mention of the Akum; for it is written (Exodus XXIII,
13):...and make no mention of other gods."
3. THEIR IDOLS MUST BE SPOKEN
OF WITH CONTEMPT In Iore Dea (146, 15) it says: "Their idols must be
destroyed, or called by contemptuous names." Ibidem, (147, 5): "It is
permitted to deride idols, and it is forbidden to say to a Goi: May your God
help you, or I hope you will succeed." Rabbi Bechai, explaining the text of
Deuteronomy about hating idolatry, says: "The Scripture teached us to hate
idols and to call them by ignominious names. Thus, if the name of a church
is Bethgalia - "house of magnificence," it should be called Bethkaria - an
insignificant house, a pigs' house, a latrine. For this word, karia, denotes
a low-down, slum place." In numerous places ignominious names are given by
the Jews to Christian things. It will not be out of place to list a few of
these names which they give to things and persons which are held holy and
dear by Christians, as follows: JESUS is ignominiously called Jeschu - which
means, May his name and memory be blotted out. His proper name in Hebrew is
Jeschua, which means Salvation. MARY, THE MOTHER OF JESUS, is called Charia
- dung, excrement (German Dreck). In Hebrew her proper name is Miriam.
CHRISTIAN SAINTS, the word for which in Hebrew Kedoschim, are called
Kededchim (cinaedos) - feminine men (Farries). Women saints are called
Kedeschoth, whores. SUNDAY is called the day of calamity. FEAST OF CHRISTMAS
is called Nital, denoting extermination. EASTER is not called by the proper
name Pesach (Passover), but Ketsach, meanin